Pot: Kettle

  • Lord Wiggle@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    4 days ago

    How could apartheid be an overreaction to that?

    Apartheid has been going on for years and years now. Just like the rest of the oppression and locking people in a closed off ghetto. Its not a reaction to Oct7. Oct7 is a reaction to apartheid (which was a terrorist act which I condemn).

    But besides that, you argue that racism, stripping people of their human rights and identity for an entire group of people is fine when a small group of terrorists commit a terrorist attack?

    Crimes against humanity are never fine. No matter what happened. When a few commit a terrorist act, or do whatever horrible thing possible, that still shouldn’t justify to become a monster yourself in general, but especially not to thousands of innocent civilians.

    The reasoning of “yeah but look what they did” was the reason nazi Germany justified deporting jews to Auschwitz. It’s the reason why the US invaded and completely wrecked Afghanistan. It’s the reason Russia invaded Ukraine and defends it’s war crimes. It’s the reason for the ethnic cleansing by Israel and why they refuse to cease fire.

    Never justify horrible acts like war crimes and crimes against humanity by saying “but look what they did” because crimes against humanity and war crimes do not have an asterisk or ammendment saying “except when-”.

    • crashfrog@lemm.ee
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      4 days ago

      Apartheid has been going on for years and years now.

      Yes, in fact it’s been going on for quite a bit fewer years than the Arabs of Palestine have been trying to commit genocide against the Jews. If you don’t think Oct 7 is somehow a brutal act of terrorism by a people who deserve apartheid (at least) as a response, then you can look to the one before that, the one before that, the one before that, and so on and so forth all the way back to the first Arabs invading Judea.

      The Jews of Israel have lived with the Palestinian desire to mass-murder them a lot longer than I would. No more merciful a people than Israelis; no more ungrateful a people than Palestinians.

      The reasoning of “yeah but look what they did” was the reason nazi Germany justified deporting jews to Auschwitz.

      If Jews had, en masse, instituted a pogrom of Germans then the camps would have been justified. But it was the reverse that was true. But the Arabs have been torturing, enslaving, and killing Jews since the first day they colonized Judea.

      • Lord Wiggle@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        4 days ago

        Clearly you have no clue of what has been going on the past 100 years over there and your sources of information are clearly propaganda as your statements are false.

        If Jews had, en masse, instituted a pogrom of Germans then the camps would have been justified.

        You claim there is a justifiable reason to have concentration camps. Because of people like you, concentration camps have been able to exist. Have you ever been to one? I have, to several including Auschwitz. I believe you are a danger to society, I hope you will never hold any position of power.

        You support and justify crimes against humanity so there is no reason for me to continue this conversation any longer.