Escalating violence and Israel's 'genocidal' campaign in Gaza spark a wave of departures, with the nation facing a brain drain and shrinking population growth
Just so you know I haven’t downvoted any of your comments.
I don’t think I have implied that anything isn’t a ‘big deal’ or that this is ‘100% positive’ or that I’m engaging in ‘black-and-white thinking’.
I did point out that Israeli settlers have been doing the things you suggest they do such as organising in opposition for decades without much success. This includes protests, campaigns, conscription and military refusal, opposition political parties and so on.
I do think if more people emigrate from Israel it will better and I linked to a piece by someone who renounced their citizenship that goes into detail about why this is the case. Perhaps if you disagree with this sentiment you could check this article out and let me know which parts you have issue with.
I don’t think I’ve taken anything you said out of context and I’d appreciate if you could pay me the same courtesy.
I wasn’t taking what you said out of context, I was interpreting it, and I also explained what I have issue with- the fact that this will make it harder to organize resistance from within.
And from the comments you have made twice now, again- this is my interpretation, you seem to be saying that there is no point in trying to resist from within. Which is a ridiculously defeatist attitude. I’m not sure why else you’re saying the resistance attempts have not had much success.
Resistance in East Germany didn’t have much success either. Until it did. See: every other authoritarian regime brought down from within.
And from the comments you have made twice now, again- this is my interpretation, you seem to be saying that there is no point in trying to resist from within.
I didn’t say this or infer it. I’m sorry but your interpretation is wrong. I agree with you, everyone who stays and wants to fight should do so. But I also don’t think this exodus will necessarily have a negative impact on any such struggle. It may even open up new spaces for new activists and organisers. We’ll see I guess.
Hold up, can we start over?
Just so you know I haven’t downvoted any of your comments.
I don’t think I have implied that anything isn’t a ‘big deal’ or that this is ‘100% positive’ or that I’m engaging in ‘black-and-white thinking’.
I did point out that Israeli settlers have been doing the things you suggest they do such as organising in opposition for decades without much success. This includes protests, campaigns, conscription and military refusal, opposition political parties and so on.
I do think if more people emigrate from Israel it will better and I linked to a piece by someone who renounced their citizenship that goes into detail about why this is the case. Perhaps if you disagree with this sentiment you could check this article out and let me know which parts you have issue with.
I don’t think I’ve taken anything you said out of context and I’d appreciate if you could pay me the same courtesy.
I wasn’t taking what you said out of context, I was interpreting it, and I also explained what I have issue with- the fact that this will make it harder to organize resistance from within.
And from the comments you have made twice now, again- this is my interpretation, you seem to be saying that there is no point in trying to resist from within. Which is a ridiculously defeatist attitude. I’m not sure why else you’re saying the resistance attempts have not had much success.
Resistance in East Germany didn’t have much success either. Until it did. See: every other authoritarian regime brought down from within.
I didn’t say this or infer it. I’m sorry but your interpretation is wrong. I agree with you, everyone who stays and wants to fight should do so. But I also don’t think this exodus will necessarily have a negative impact on any such struggle. It may even open up new spaces for new activists and organisers. We’ll see I guess.