Idk if this is the work of AI, or just a 3D artist who didnāt get very good instructions for their commission.
At first glance: nothing special, just a collection of random instruments; but when you start to dissect it under the lens of a surgical tech (the target audience for this image) it just gets worse and worse.
So letās dissect it!
First off, that isnāt even a surgical backtable - it appears to be on some kind of supply cart, with a raised lip around the edges, and random rectangular holes for handles that have folded sheet metal along the edge. Technically you could throw an impervious drape of that and itād be fine, but you generally donāt see surfaces made to support a sterile field with raised edges that go above the field. The folded sheet metal is also a no-no, as the grooves around it collect and breed the hell out of bacteria.
None of itās draped. Thereās that greenish material under the tray and instruments, but stops short of the edges of the cart, so thereās some REALLY high contamination potential going on there. You could get away with a field like that in dental (which is just ācleanā vs sterile), but again, this wasnāt sent for a dental tech position.
Instruments from left to right, weāre looking at:
-
a scalpel thatās for some reason separate from all the other sharps in the kidney basin.
-
looks like a tissue forcep - that actually checks out.
-
ā¦the only times Iāve seen a forcep like have been in ortho sets that have a lot of plates and screws - those forceps are to grab the tiny screws from their caddy, cuz theyāre hard to get your fingers around, and normal forceps tend to āslipā around the head of the screw and send it flying across the OR.
-
thatās a sponge forcep, but the end is bent in a really odd way; and it doesnāt have a ratchet lock, which isnāt unheard of, but definitely not common for a sponge forcep.
-
Dental explorer, which checks out with the whole not-really-sterile thing; except if it was a dental setup thereād be a lot more dental instruments.
-
Fuck if I know. Doesnāt help that the resolution isnāt great, but the operative ends kind of look flat. Bowel clamps are shaped like that, but that is DEFINITELY not an open-belly setup lol. Also - the ringed end where your fingers would go is closed all the way, but the operational end is still open. If a real instrument looks like that, then itās damaged as fuck and needs to be thrown away.
-
Either a kocher clamp or straight hemostat - hard to tell w/ shitty res. But they have have the same weirdness with the ratchet being closed w/ operation end still open.
-
That looks like a potts scissor, which is usually for vascular surgery. Handle is janky as fuck though, and itās doing the opposite weirdness as mentioned before: itās operative end is closed all the way, but the handles are still a tad open.
-
Mayo scissors, which are a go-to for cutting suture. Only weirdness here is the janky handle style.
ā¦and that kidney basin in the upper right of the tray is just chock-full of WTF. So theyāre using it as a sharps container - thatās normal, but theyāve got the scalpels facing one direction and needles facing the otherā¦ thatās a good way to get stabbed. ALL of the sharps are resting on the edge, meaning if you bump them just right, theyāll do a flip and launch offā¦ thatās a good way to get stabbed. Theyāve got all their sharps in one spot, except for that one random scalpel on the left of the tray. Establishing a sharps zone and then not putting sharps in itā¦ thatās a good way to get stabbed. The scalpels and needles in the kidney basin all have the sharp end stuck into some gauze or somethingā¦ thatāll dull or bend the super fine end, reducing its effectiveness and generating snag points thatāll cause a bit of unnecessary trauma. Between the three scalpels in the basin and the bonus one floating off to the left, a solid third of the instruments displayed are scalpels lolā¦ are they doing a Wolverine cosplay in the OR?? The blades detachā¦ you only need one scalpel handle - maybe two if you want one ready and on stand by. Also all of them are loaded with what looks like a #24 scalpel blade, which isnāt very common; and is a fucking massive bladeā¦ I could see wanting ONE of those for something like an emergency C-section when you need to rip that skin open fucking NOW, but 4 of those monsters set up with an otherwise tiny collection of instruments? lol no. Those two syringes arenāt capped, which is a good way to get stabbed; or labeled, which is a good way mix up your local anesthetic with something that could cause excruciating pain.
ā¦thereās just so much wrong with this image itās comical. I canāt believe a fucking hospital would choose this over the millions of OR photos already floating around the web lol.
That was a fun rant to type up. If you actually read that wall of text, hope you got a kick out of it lol!
I like this post because it goes a long way to proving that highly technical jobs have depths of nuance that your average laymen will never even consider.
Like when you see āhackingā in movies, as an IT guy it makes me hardcringe every time.
Another example of this is how Hollywood portrays āpoorā families as having houses 3x larger than anything you could ever afford and two cars but they are just making sad faces all the time.
Because thatās what struggling is to hollywood writers, they lack the nuance to understand what being poor really means.
The problem is that these media images being made are MORE compelling to people who donāt understand the nuance. That tray of utensils looks fine to me as a knowlessman and I would feel that whatever content was hosting it was medically reliable.
You as a professional know it is ridiculous only because you have the practical experience that the artist lacked.
The real danger is when people start believing the artist more because of how much more aesthetically pleasing they can make their misunderstandings, and trust me it is a real danger.
We already have that a lot in our field - people just buy a shiny UI, and donāt care about the rest.
One of the first times Iāve encountered that was when a customer bought a ridiculously overpriced firewall box because of the easy to use GUI, and asked me to implement a pretty complex rule set. The irony of having bought the fancy UI so the can do it themselves, and then hire an expert to do it instead was completely lost on them.
This thing had troubles doing what was needed there, and had pretty much zero debug functionality exposed - so eventually I suggested they give me one of their old desktops and half a day to see if I can get the ruleset done the old fashioned way with OpenBSDs pf (that was before Linux kernel 2.4 was released, so Linux firewalls couldnāt do stateful filtering yet, which was required there) - got everything running in a morning, they decided to just stick with it, and the expensive fancy box was collecting dust.