My daughter has picked up an interest in Demon Slayer, however having watched a little I think it’s too violent/mature.

I’d love to foster her interest in these things, by trying out an alternative anime that hits similar notes while being more age apropriate.

Any recommendations?

  • fireweed@lemmy.worldEnglish
    1·
    9 months ago

    Again, I’ve only read the manga so I don’t know how they’re portrayed in the anime, but:

    Yuzuriha: primary purpose is motivation for the male protagonist (ala Miho Asuki in Bakuman)

    Kohaku: min-maxed strength and dexterity at the loss of intelligence, wisdom, and self-initiative (and I’m sorry, but that is one ridiculously skimpy outfit, especially given her acrobatic role)

    Suika: pre-pubescent characters (thankfully!) usually bypass misogyny/hypersexualization so I don’t include her in my assessment

    And then there are the other first-half characters, like:

    Ruri: helpless sick girl (omg that shot of her being fed medicine)

    Kirisame: zero self-initiative (mindlessly follows orders), and that outfit makes Kohaku look like a nun

    And a bunch more that I don’t remember because it’s been a while since I read the series.

    The first female character I didn’t feel at least a little uncomfortable about was Chelsea, who I think is actually a strong character and the first (non-child) female character to be accepted into the group for her insight, smarts, and decision-making skills, AND her design is not sexualized (almost as if she stumbled in from another series). But she appears quite late in the series, hence my comment about the first half. Some of the American female characters are also okay, but not great (and again, introduced in the latter half). But even towards the end, the male characters are in nearly all the leadership positions, and the female characters are left to play support.

    I don’t mean to single out Dr Stone; you could do a similar analysis for most anime and nearly all shonen series. But especially given the gender imbalance in STEM, it’s unfortunate to see more business as usual.

    • Gabu@lemmy.worldEnglish
      12·
      9 months ago

      the male characters are in nearly all the leadership positions, and the female characters are left to play support.

      Wow, almost like it’s a traditional SHOUNEN.

      Yuzuriha: primary purpose is motivation for the male protagonist

      Straight up false, she’s only seen as an idol before being revived (understandably so, what the hell can a stone do except look pretty). Immediately after, she’s treated as a skilled member of the party. I’ll give you that the author loves drawing her from behind.

      Kohaku: min-maxed strength and dexterity at the loss of intelligence, wisdom, and self-initiative

      Again, false. She’s not dumb, if anything she’s pretty smart and on top of things - only she doesn’t have any knowledge of the civilized world, being a new-worlder and all that. I went through the manga, and from chapter 9 (her introduction) to chapter 26 (got bored after that), there are a total of 5 panels where she’s “sexualized”, all of which self-censored by either scenery or speech bubbles.

      Ruri: helpless sick girl (omg that shot of her being fed medicine)

      OK, that shot was “sus”, as the zoomers say, but being a helpless sick girl was an essential part of the plot, not some fanservice or male superiority complex.

      Kirisame: zero self-initiative (mindlessly follows orders), and that outfit makes Kohaku look like a nun

      During the first half she’s just a goon, which is what I’d actually like to address here - if anything, the later parts of the story lose focus and start being more about fanservice.