We could prove it by my doing a study on all the people that rejected medicine in fav our of alternatives. Hkwever, we might find it hard. They are dead.
Dara O’Brian has a great but about what you call alternative medicine that is proven to work. We just call it medicine.
…what you call alternative medicine that is proven to work. We just call it medicine.
In fairness, that’s only if there is an existing incentive to put forward the time and the funds for multiple controlled and peer-reviewed studies.
I think almost all alternative medicine is bollocks, but alternative medicine is drawn from historical records and/or anecdotal experience. This is flawed but is also how we obtained many of the medicines we use today. Controlled and peer-reviewed studies now allow them to be called ‘medicine’ instead of ‘alternative medicine’.
I used to be completely against alternative medicine, but after a particularly awful toothache while my wisdom teeth were erupting, the established medicine salicylic acid (which itself originates from willow) was utterly ineffective, I tried the alternative medicine clove oil out of desperation. It is now the only alternative medicine I recommend. There have been studies showing it’s effectiveness, but nothing particularly notable, and why would there be? Who would be able to patent it? It is already very cheap and readily available. I wonder how many other effective treatments are underutilised because there has been inadequate research.
That being said… I won’t be drinking bleach any time soon, and as a major contributor to death globally there is a very strong incentive to research cancer treatments. Any alternative medicine claiming to treat cancer is highly dubious IMO.
Edit: In hindsight, it’s a legitimate concern that some people may read my post and take it as an excuse not to take advantage of existing treatments. I only want to acknowledge that there is sometimes a market disincentive to research existing but unapproved treatments, I don’t want people to think it’s okay to kill their child.
Clove oil is used by dentists. It’s in alvogyl, which is used as an ointment for wisdom tooth probkems. That’s the point, if there is evidence it works, it becomes actual medicine, not alternstive medicine.
Yee, research is costly, yet we managed to create an entire medical industry with peer reviewed research before the rise of big pharma. Alternative medicine has lots of practitioners selling a product. Not so much research. It’s a multi billion industry. If consumers demanded it, or regulators for that matter, you can bet they’d do rrsearch. Some would probably survive (see acupuncture for back problems) however most would be proven ineffective.
The part of alvogyl derived from clove oil (and some other oils) is eugenol.
As a ‘coincidence’ eugenol is currently approved in the US as a ‘flavouring substance’. From what I could find it has no official recognition for its medical properties. I expect dentists don’t really care if one of the major ingredients of a medication they use is a ‘flavouring substance’.
Wife nil has been used for pain relief in dentistry for many yesrs… The FDA does not consider clove oil a medicine as the evidence for it is poor.
That’s how nedicine works. Someone thinks something would help. We do studies… Find out of it works and in what circumstances. Eugenol, which is the active ingredient in clove oik, not a derivatuin, works for pericoronitis and alveolar osteitis. It also works for pulpal inflammation, but it’s use is reducing as it inhibits modern dental bonding.
Dentists care about what ingredients work to aid pain more than fkavour. They don’t care if it is derived from traditional cures or not. They look at the evidence. When it worjs, they call it medicine, which is my point.
It looks like you’re contradicting yourself to me. You argue that clove oil is a medicine so my claim it should be considered one doesn’t apply, then you come back and say the evidence that it is a medicine is poor, which is why it is not approved by the FDA… Which is exactly MY point.
Clove oil is no longer used, medically, but eugenol is used in multiple dental medicines to have a proven pain relief effect.
Right. You are still claiming that eugenol is considered to be medicinal… Here is a database of all FDA medicines approved for human use. Why not show me a single medication that uses eugenol as an active ingredient?
The essential oils industry is rife with scams and “alternative science” but some of them do actually have some (usually not as miraculous as their sellers want you to believe) actual effects.
Wait, I’m going to call a very famous person that loves alternative medicine, Steve Jobs. Whoops, no he’s dead because he refused to get his totally treatable cancer cured by science and chose quackery instead.
A lot of research does not need capitalist incentives. Research to develop a new class of drugs is expensive. Research to see if a common treatment is effective is much less costly. Good evidence is also repeatable for verification.
The reason alternative medicine does not have evidence is indeed capitslism. You make more profit selling unproven cheap remedies than bothering to do research. It’s not the converse, that alternative medicine is blocked out of research due to cost.
We could prove it by my doing a study on all the people that rejected medicine in fav our of alternatives. Hkwever, we might find it hard. They are dead.
Dara O’Brian has a great but about what you call alternative medicine that is proven to work. We just call it medicine.
In fairness, that’s only if there is an existing incentive to put forward the time and the funds for multiple controlled and peer-reviewed studies.
I think almost all alternative medicine is bollocks, but alternative medicine is drawn from historical records and/or anecdotal experience. This is flawed but is also how we obtained many of the medicines we use today. Controlled and peer-reviewed studies now allow them to be called ‘medicine’ instead of ‘alternative medicine’.
I used to be completely against alternative medicine, but after a particularly awful toothache while my wisdom teeth were erupting, the established medicine salicylic acid (which itself originates from willow) was utterly ineffective, I tried the alternative medicine clove oil out of desperation. It is now the only alternative medicine I recommend. There have been studies showing it’s effectiveness, but nothing particularly notable, and why would there be? Who would be able to patent it? It is already very cheap and readily available. I wonder how many other effective treatments are underutilised because there has been inadequate research.
That being said… I won’t be drinking bleach any time soon, and as a major contributor to death globally there is a very strong incentive to research cancer treatments. Any alternative medicine claiming to treat cancer is highly dubious IMO.
Edit: In hindsight, it’s a legitimate concern that some people may read my post and take it as an excuse not to take advantage of existing treatments. I only want to acknowledge that there is sometimes a market disincentive to research existing but unapproved treatments, I don’t want people to think it’s okay to kill their child.
Clove oil is used by dentists. It’s in alvogyl, which is used as an ointment for wisdom tooth probkems. That’s the point, if there is evidence it works, it becomes actual medicine, not alternstive medicine.
Yee, research is costly, yet we managed to create an entire medical industry with peer reviewed research before the rise of big pharma. Alternative medicine has lots of practitioners selling a product. Not so much research. It’s a multi billion industry. If consumers demanded it, or regulators for that matter, you can bet they’d do rrsearch. Some would probably survive (see acupuncture for back problems) however most would be proven ineffective.
The part of alvogyl derived from clove oil (and some other oils) is eugenol.
As a ‘coincidence’ eugenol is currently approved in the US as a ‘flavouring substance’. From what I could find it has no official recognition for its medical properties. I expect dentists don’t really care if one of the major ingredients of a medication they use is a ‘flavouring substance’.
Wife nil has been used for pain relief in dentistry for many yesrs… The FDA does not consider clove oil a medicine as the evidence for it is poor.
That’s how nedicine works. Someone thinks something would help. We do studies… Find out of it works and in what circumstances. Eugenol, which is the active ingredient in clove oik, not a derivatuin, works for pericoronitis and alveolar osteitis. It also works for pulpal inflammation, but it’s use is reducing as it inhibits modern dental bonding.
Dentists care about what ingredients work to aid pain more than fkavour. They don’t care if it is derived from traditional cures or not. They look at the evidence. When it worjs, they call it medicine, which is my point.
It looks like you’re contradicting yourself to me. You argue that clove oil is a medicine so my claim it should be considered one doesn’t apply, then you come back and say the evidence that it is a medicine is poor, which is why it is not approved by the FDA… Which is exactly MY point.
Ok, let me rephrase to simplify.
Alternative medicine is unproven folk medicine.
Sometimes the idea is sound.
Studying outcomes of its use can legitimise it or show it is bunk.
Clove oil was studied. Eugenol being the active ingredient.
Clove oil is no longer used, medically, but eugenol is used in multiple dental medicines to have a proven pain relief effect.
It is now medicine.
Clove oil on its own does not have sufficient evidence to be useful. Eugenol built in to other medicines and restorativedoes.
That’s the progression from alternative medicine to medicine.
Right. You are still claiming that eugenol is considered to be medicinal… Here is a database of all FDA medicines approved for human use. Why not show me a single medication that uses eugenol as an active ingredient?
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3702691/#:~:text=Numerous studies have reported that,use in oral care products.
Look at paragraph 2
For FDA, you likely won’t find them as they are exepmt,as this listing for commonly used zinc oxide eugenol cobfirns.
https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfpcd/classification.cfm?id=EMB
The essential oils industry is rife with scams and “alternative science” but some of them do actually have some (usually not as miraculous as their sellers want you to believe) actual effects.
Wait, I’m going to call a very famous person that loves alternative medicine, Steve Jobs. Whoops, no he’s dead because he refused to get his totally treatable cancer cured by science and chose quackery instead.
“… and I don’t care who gets the worst of it.”
deleted by creator
“I’m sorry, it seems harsh, I used to be much more generous about it…”
A lot of research does not need capitalist incentives. Research to develop a new class of drugs is expensive. Research to see if a common treatment is effective is much less costly. Good evidence is also repeatable for verification.
The reason alternative medicine does not have evidence is indeed capitslism. You make more profit selling unproven cheap remedies than bothering to do research. It’s not the converse, that alternative medicine is blocked out of research due to cost.